Perfect Pancake Maker
New Product Review:

Perfect Pancake Maker

From Various Manufacturers
Reviewed by Mr Breakfast on 10/14/2003

I was so excited for this product to arrive. The clever pan-on-pan design seemed so simple; I wondered why these pans haven't been popular for ages. The TV commercial that prompted me to buy Perfect Pancake showed a hand flipping the pan to make over-hard eggs without breaking the yolks. Seemed easy. I tried it. One flip of the pan and my eggs slid out of the pan, across the stove and onto the floor.

So it didn't work for eggs. I could forgive that; afterall I bought my dual-pan under the name the Perfect Pancake maker. I tried making pancakes several times. Regardless of batter-consitency, all of my pancakes came out thick and hearty. Even a crepe-thin coating produced thick silver-nickels.

Final verdict: Beyond the novelty and fun-design, this product is good for only one thing: thick pancakes. Forget making eggs or more delicate batter-cakes. The real perfect pancake maker is still a solid pan and a spatula.

The price we paid: $19.99

 (2 out of 7 Golden Eggs)
Comments About This Product Review
What do you think of Perfect Pancake Maker?
By canes

Product Rating (out of 5):

Try using butter, Pam or a teaspoon of oil. For both eggs and pancakes. You will be surprised.

Comment submitted: 5/28/2014 (#5054)

By superman

Product Rating (out of 5):

This product makes big mess all over the stove and the heart-shaped one was a joke!

Comment submitted: 3/21/2014 (#4898)

By pen

I got this as a present for Christmas. Was so excited. It took so long for them to get done and I actually burnt them. It seemed a waste of my time. They did come out easily though. Still wouldn't recommend it.

Comment submitted: 1/3/2014 (#4827)

By Moe-Moe

Product Rating (out of 5):

I love the Perfect Pancake Maker! We made hot sandwiches for years, they always turned out perfect and delicious. But then I dropped it down the basement stairs. So sad. Have been looking to purchase a new one but haven't found it anywhere. I would recommend this pan to everyone. It's easy to use and quick clean up.

Comment submitted: 2/16/2013 (#3604)

By Linda

So if you wait until the eggs set and then flip, it works fine. Do the eggs get hard?

Comment submitted: 12/21/2012 (#3547)

By josh

Product Rating (out of 5):

The biggest waste of money and metal. I took mine, used it to make one pancake, took it off the stove and threw it outside.

Comment submitted: 12/8/2012 (#3539)

By art angel

Product Rating (out of 5):

I liked it. I can finally make a decent shaped pancake now... wow.

Comment submitted: 1/1/2012 (#2962)

By taco

Looks cool. Too bad it doesn't work so good.

Comment submitted: 10/12/2011 (#2908)

By panman

Product Rating (out of 5):

We have 2 of these, 1 works perfectly and doesn't stick at all, the other one no matter what you do the pancakes stick to it (it is in great looking condition)... Also, the handles seem to break fairly easily. I now use a regular pan, much more convenient.

Comment submitted: 1/10/2011 (#2663)

By gift from son

Product Rating (out of 5):

My husband and I love this. Son gave it to us. Glad I tried it. Best, best pancakes ever.

Comment submitted: 9/19/2010 (#2526)

Official Member: Team BreakfastBy roadie6r (Team Breakfast Member)

Product Rating (out of 5):

My wife has had this product for 5 years now and it makes perfect pancakes. A lot of people have criticized it, but a local news caster here in Jacksonville proved to a non believer that it really works. You just have to be smarter than the pan.

Comment submitted: 7/5/2010 (#2404)

By NanaKP

Product Rating (out of 5):

I need to replace my "Perfect Pancake" pan. The teflon coating has some scratches, but I still use it and it still works great. Big fluffy pancakes, all kinds of eggs, great grilled cheese. I owned this before I met my husband and we celebrated our 30th anniversary this year. The key is not to turn the heat too high. Don't try to flip it while egg, pancake, etc., is still liquid. duh

Comment submitted: 1/30/2010 (#2120)

By Jack

Product Rating (out of 5):

Please don't buy this product. All its good for is making a huge mess all over the stove. Non stick, what a joke even after greasing the pan, it still stuck. I gave this thing one last try yesterday and after making a mess with it I literally broke it in half. Use a good griddle.

Comment submitted: 1/26/2010 (#2110)

By sxysinger

Product Rating (out of 5):

I am not a fan of pancakes, but someone gave this to me as a wedding gift. I used it for about 4 years for Tuna Melts, grilled cheese, eggs, etc.... I love it and i was sad when all the non stick coating fell off. I am buying a new one and hope it is as fabulous as my original!

Comment submitted: 11/16/2009 (#2005)

By G-Max

Product Rating (out of 5):

The commercials specifically mention the ability to make omelets. I tried making one, and egg goes all over the stove and floor. Worthless piece of garbage, do not buy.

Comment submitted: 10/29/2009 (#1978)

By richie

Product Rating (out of 5):

I made hotdogs in the perfect pancake pan and they turned out yummy.

Comment submitted: 9/26/2009 (#1940)

By great product

Product Rating (out of 5):

We bought our first pancake maker about 3 years ago and used it until it fell apart. We purchased and second one and love it for pancakes, grilled cheese sandwiches, I even fry eggs in it. It is wonderful... so wonderful I'm getting another one just to have as a back-up.

Comment submitted: 5/6/2009 (#1646)

By Cash Money

Product Rating (out of 5):

I had to remove the heating things they had and install new ones that keep the seal.

Comment submitted: 2/14/2009 (#1467)

By Bud

Product Rating (out of 5):

Worst Product i have EVER had. It sticks to the pan, and it is a big wast of money.

Comment submitted: 1/3/2009 (#1353)

Official Member: Team BreakfastBy theriver989 (Team Breakfast Member)

Product Rating (out of 5):

I have had my perfect pancake maker for over 6 years at first it sat in cupboard and I never used it. About 2 years ago I started using it and wow I can't believe how big and wonderful the pancakes turn out. They are bigger and better than resturants. I need a new one and I was so pleased to see that I can get a new one. I thought I have had this for so long and no way I'll find one now. I'm am so excited that I can replace it.

Comment submitted: 6/7/2008 (#1049)

By sublyme9

Product Rating (out of 5):

When I moved into my new apartment, one of these pans had been left behind by the last tenant. I tried it out today, and it worked beautifully! The first one I made, however, got stuck to the pan when i tried flipping... but after coating it with more butter, the rest of the crepes came out smoothly. I used a recipe found here.

They were perfectly thin and delicious. If your pancakes came out too thick maybe you used the wrong kind of recipe? You only need a few tablespoons of batter and then spread it around thinly in the pan. I'll definitely be using this again, and I look forward to trying it out on grilled cheese and tuna melts!

Comment submitted: 1/19/2008 (#838)

By UncleLiebby

Product Rating (out of 5):


Comment submitted: 8/29/2007 (#644)

Official Member: Team BreakfastBy CarolynGrantham (Team Breakfast Member)

Product Rating (out of 5):

Yeah, I got sucked in, too. The results are neither perfect nor pancake. I'll stick to my griddle!

Comment submitted: 8/1/2007 (#576)

By Not That Bad

Product Rating (out of 5):

Oh, give them a break.

Comment submitted: 7/19/2007 (#549)


Thank you for the confirmations. When I saw the "As seen on TV" single pancake maker, I thought those same things. Why make only one pancake at a time and, this thing looks like junk. There are websites available that may be able to answer your return questions. Thank you, -John J. Arizona

Comment submitted: 6/30/2007 (#529)

By melissaH

Hello. I'm not sure if you are the one how makes this product the perfect pancake maker or if you just sell it if you just sell in can you tell me how to contact the person or company who does because I bought this thing and it fell apart within a week the store I bought it from wont do anything to help me so im stuck with junk ( I know your not suppose to be available in stores but you and I both know the as seen on TV things are available in some store and I did get it in a store) I want some answers and I want to know who to contact about this to lodge a complaint on this product I a very very upset and dissatisfied customer!!! I expect to hear back from someone soon thank you for you time

Melissa Hollis
15201 Clearwater Trail #204
Chesterfield Virginia 23832

Comment submitted: 5/21/2007 (#475)

Official Member: Team BreakfastBy SpartyFan (Team Breakfast Member)

Product Rating (out of 5):

A friend had one of these pans and didn't like it so she let me try it. What a waste of money! Who wants to make one pancake at a time - and a really thick one at that. Like Mr.Breakfast, I'll take a good pan or griddle any day.

Comment submitted: 1/29/2007 (#249)

Comment On This Product:

Enter Your Comments Here:

Rate This Product:

Rotten Pretty Bad Okay Very Good Awesome

I Prefer Not To Rate This Product

Security Question:
Please type the name of the cereal below.

Please type the name of this cereal in the space to the right

Please enter the name of the cereal to the left:

See All Breakfast Product Reviews

Connect With Mr Breakfast:

Mr Breakfast At FaceBook
Mr Breakfast On Twitter
Mr Breakfast On Pinterest

Most Recent
Product Reviews:
Retro Breakfast & Brunch Recipes
Check out our favorite vintage recipes from old magazine ads and recipe cards. Click here.