Cereal Project > Post Toasties > All Comments

Post Toasties
All Comments For
Post Toasties Cereal
Average Rating = 5 (out of 5)

By Stargazer83 (Team Breakfast Member)

Rating (out of 5):

With all do respect, I have to disagree with the others. I was born in 65 and ate my share of Post Toasties and found that Kellogg's Corn Flakes had a much better corn taste. Another long running cereal has just ended production... Alpha Bits is no longer around.

Comment submitted: 6/18/2020 (#25296)

By kard

Why did Post discontinue Post Toasties?

Comment submitted: 10/28/2019 (#24641)

By Postman

Rating (out of 5):

What a cool story @JohnKP.

Comment submitted: 12/18/2018 (#23773)

By JohnKP (Team Breakfast Member)

I am now 97. In my youth, I was a follower of Inspector Post and applied for all of the official badges. I was still with him when he was reported to have gone to South America on a case. I miss him.

Comment submitted: 12/16/2018 (#23771)

By suzannee

Rating (out of 5):

LOVE Post Toasties, and have since a kid. I used to bake with them until they disappeared... now I'm disappointed. Would be ELATED if they were brought back on the shelves! So much better for you than those 'sugar-coated' cereals! And TASTE better too!

Comment submitted: 10/2/2018 (#23543)


Rating (out of 5):

I, too, miss this cereal. The current corn cereals just do not have that great taste! - MHJ

Comment submitted: 4/12/2018 (#22918)


Rating (out of 5):

I agree with some of the other reviews. Post Toasties corn flakes were much better than some of the other brands of corn flakes. By CJ

Comment submitted: 2/4/2017 (#21351)

By L.O.V.E. Toasties

I loved Post Toasties. Why is it when they have a great product they quit making it and go with the yucky stuff ugh. I know they won't bring them back. That's the way life is with the people in power that run the show. Marjorie Merriweather Post is dead by now. I guess so goes Post Toasties.

Comment submitted: 12/22/2016 (#21160)

By ggarner4 (Team Breakfast Member)

Rating (out of 5):

Please return Post Toasties Cereal to us. None other will do. - Gail Garner

Comment submitted: 12/1/2016 (#21087)

By Old Cop

Post Toasties had a much better flavor than that popular corn flake cereal that remains on the store shelves. I don't know when Post stopped making their cereal, I just know that it disappeared from the shelves a number of years ago. Too bad. If I could buy them again I would throw my current box into the trash.

Comment submitted: 12/1/2016 (#21085)

By Roy A.

Rating (out of 5):

Loved Post Toasties, also love Post Raisin Bran. Ate many a truck load, but then Post Toasties disappeared... what a shame. In my opinion, all the others look and taste alike... junk. Just an old man's thoughts.

Comment submitted: 9/27/2016 (#20872)


Rating (out of 5):

ADMIT IT, all the former Post Toasties are now going into Honey Bunches Of Oats. Probably more profit there.

Comment submitted: 8/22/2016 (#20733)

By graham (Team Breakfast Member)

Rating (out of 5):

I had them in South Africa from about 1942. They had airplane paper cut-outs on the box to make planes. The cereal and the planes made my days! Like lots of others, I would like them back. Kellogg's are a very poor competitor I am afraid. - Vic Fry

Comment submitted: 5/27/2016 (#20351)

By Hooked

Rating (out of 5):

I ate Post Toasties for breakfast all the time as a kid (giving away my age). I loved them. Then somewhere in the 2010-2011 time frame, I found Post Toasties in a Wegmans just north of Chicago in Michigan. I got hooked on them all over again. Then they disappeared once more. Bring them back, PLEASE! I love them - better than any cereal made now. I eat very little cereal now, but I'd have Post Toasties everyday if they sold them.

Comment submitted: 5/15/2016 (#20306)

By ducky

Rating (out of 5):

Favorite cereal since childhood, along with Rice Krinkles and I guess both are now discontinued. I don't understand why these are unavailable, yet all those other yucky cereals fill the shelves. I WANT MY POST TOASTIES BACK! The only brand worth eating!

Comment submitted: 3/26/2016 (#20106)

By k.p.

Rating (out of 5):

Really! When did they stop making them and why! Please bring them back!

Comment submitted: 12/9/2015 (#19735)

By Yabbie

Rating (out of 5):

Loved them as a kid and wish they would come back.

Comment submitted: 6/15/2015 (#19128)

By Mad Rhonda

Rating (out of 5):

I am mystified about what has happened to Post Toasties. Even on their web page, in the history section, I see no listing for Post Toasties. There is only Kellogg's (yuck) and store brand flakes. Really? There is NOTHING like a good bowl of Post Toasties and milk. Please bring it back.

Comment submitted: 5/17/2015 (#19017)

By Sonya C.

Rating (out of 5):

What the heck? I thought they brought these back but I cannot find them anywhere. Other corn flakes don't even taste like they've been toasted at all. Please increase the stocking on these best corn flakes ever, Port Toasties!!!

Comment submitted: 4/29/2015 (#18956)

By Robert in TX

Rating (out of 5):

Never heard of a company dropping a line it made a profit on. Guess the price of corn may be the issue, now that so much is used for bio-fuels. But, it is our loss. No other cornflake has the crispiness and flavor of Post Toasties - the definition of what a corn flake should be.

Comment submitted: 2/19/2015 (#18566)

By Dee

Rating (out of 5):

How can a product that's far superior to any other offered be discontinued? Who makes these decisions? Post Toasties were the best cornflake cereal ever made, couldn't be beat. Please consider bringing them back to the market ASAP.

Comment submitted: 2/17/2015 (#18549)

By Tex Me

Rating (out of 5):

I truly miss my Post Toasties! Good anytime of day... loved them most as an evening snack... and they made the best corn-flake, peanut-butter treats! I hardly visit the cereal aisle anymore. :(

Comment submitted: 12/8/2014 (#18139)

By MissKat

I searched high and I searched low, but no Post Toasties could be found. I kept thinking they'd re-appear. There is no other corn flake worth buying.

Comment submitted: 8/9/2014 (#17474)

By corvetteguy (Team Breakfast Member)

Rating (out of 5):

Is there a lawsuit against Post Toasties? If not, bring it back. Kellogg's is not the same. Surely Post Toaties has better recognition than many others! - Ron

Comment submitted: 8/4/2014 (#17455)

By Miss Toasties

Rating (out of 5):

I miss Post Toasties. I will NOT eat ANY Post cereal until they bring it back!

Comment submitted: 3/30/2014 (#16543)

By Like The Name

Rating (out of 5):

I love Post Toasties... but only because of the name. They're just corn flakes. They all taste the same.

Comment submitted: 10/28/2013 (#15223)

By birdman

Rating (out of 5):

Post Toasties was briefly re-introduced to the market a few years ago, and I wish I had stockpiled a supply. Nowhere to be found now. Beats Kellogg's Corn Flakes hands down.

Comment submitted: 10/17/2013 (#15159)

By Duke

Rating (out of 5):

Without a doubt, the best cereal I ever had. I wish I had some right now!

Comment submitted: 10/15/2013 (#15061)

By corney

Rating (out of 5):

Best cereal of all-time! Great memories! I even remember that Andy Griffith commercial.

Comment submitted: 9/9/2013 (#13855)

By zerovoltz

Rating (out of 5):

The Walmart brand corn flakes apparently are manufactured on former Post lines... taste just like Toasties!

Comment submitted: 6/29/2013 (#12587)

By Diabetic

Rating (out of 5):

Bring it back! There's no other cereal like it! It's the best cereal and it is recommended for diabetics! Help us stay healthy...

Comment submitted: 5/18/2013 (#12121)

By brotherben

If they ever start making Post Toasties again, would someone please let me know at brotherben at marktwain dot net. Thank you! -Ben

Comment submitted: 3/21/2013 (#11344)

By C.Wilson

Rating (out of 5):

This was the best cereal ever. I don't understand... this was such a great cereal that obviously we all love. I too grew up on this cereal and wanted my children to know what a good cereal really tastes like.

Comment submitted: 2/2/2013 (#10614)

By andy f (Team Breakfast Member)

Rating (out of 5):

It was discontinued in favor of Honey Bunches of Oats.

Comment submitted: 1/4/2013 (#10287)

By XmasWish

Rating (out of 5):

My aunt wants a box of Post Toasties for Christmas and I can't find any. Please bring them back!

Comment submitted: 12/21/2012 (#10178)

By Bessie

Rating (out of 5):

I was devastated when I could no longer buy Post Toasties. I didn't know there was any other brand of corn flakes! I cannot get them in our area (NM) but read they had reintroduced them. Help!

Comment submitted: 11/23/2012 (#9995)

By carolynfultz (Team Breakfast Member)

Post Toasties Corn Flakes are the best brand ever! I have had my son looking for them. I did not know they weren't being made anymore. Please, Post, reconsider and bring them back. Breakfast has not been the same without them.

Comment submitted: 10/29/2012 (#9778)

By Jackie

Rating (out of 5):

We have been looking for Post Toasties and couldn't find it any where. Please bring it back. It's much better than Kellogg's Corn Flakes. By Jackie.

Comment submitted: 9/22/2012 (#9202)

By OldeFortran

Rating (out of 5):

Best. Cereal. Ever. Please bring it back!

Comment submitted: 8/30/2012 (#8956)

By debduns

Rating (out of 5):

Please bring back Post Toasties! My mom and I have our bowls and milk ready.

Comment submitted: 5/29/2012 (#7825)

By susie

Rating (out of 5):

My mother is 97 and wants me to get her some Post Toasties corn flakes, which I can't find anywhere. She says they are the best.

Comment submitted: 5/25/2012 (#7740)

By M. M. from F.W.

Rating (out of 5):

Like the rest, I beg you to bring back the cereal that I grew up on and enjoyed each day.

Comment submitted: 5/14/2012 (#7670)

By M. Quimby

Rating (out of 5):

Please bring back Post Toasties!

Comment submitted: 4/24/2012 (#7382)

By Vessie

Rating (out of 5):

There's a special place in H--- for the corprate moron who signed off on dropping Toasties.

Comment submitted: 2/21/2012 (#6578)

By k-swiss

Since Ralcorp formally known as Ralston Purina took over the Post cereal company, most of the corn flakes production went to private label and the Ralston banner. Dollar General temporary sold the Post Toasties brand last year.

Comment submitted: 1/26/2012 (#6296)

By chance

Rating (out of 5):

I always liked these flakes better than the ones from Kellogg's.

Comment submitted: 1/24/2012 (#6282)

By cecil

I have a Vintage Post Toasties Giant Economy Size cereal box and was wondering what it is worth. If anyone knows please e-mail me at gcreasor@yahoo.com. Thanks.

Comment submitted: 1/16/2012 (#6207)

By penny

Rating (out of 5):

My husband will not eat any of the corn flakes I have been able to find since Post Toasties went out of production. Please return them to our shelves! They are the cereal most wanted by most of my family members, even the young ones. Kellogg's Corn Flakes just don't cut it and neither do any of the store brands. - A. Sissom

Comment submitted: 1/11/2012 (#6169)

By L. Case

Rating (out of 5):

Please Post, put Post Toasties back in the stores. It's the best cereal in the history of cereal.

Comment submitted: 1/5/2012 (#6122)

By JimmieLou

Rating (out of 5):

I keep looking for Post Toasties, but alas none on the shelves. I have had to resort to Kellogg Corn Flakes and they get soggy too quick in the milk. I'm 74 and hope to get this cereal before I die. Please put them back on the shelves. Jimmie Lou

Comment submitted: 12/4/2011 (#5880)

By Gabi Erna

Rating (out of 5):

How do I get that t shirt for my dad??? Email me at gabierna@hotmail.com please. I would love to get it for him in an XL man size. He had it when he was a kid and would it for his birthday. Thank you

Comment submitted: 4/7/2011 (#4287)

By fossilroe

Rating (out of 5):

Bring back Post Toasties!!!

Comment submitted: 4/2/2011 (#4255)

By Bring It Back

Rating (out of 5):

I found Post Toasties in Woodmans in Wisconson in March 2010, but its spot was empty in October 2010 - and remains so now per relative up there.

Comment submitted: 11/17/2010 (#3287)

By Tejal

I found Post Toasties in Woodmans in Illinois.

Comment submitted: 3/5/2010 (#1551)

By freeme

Rating (out of 5):

It's hard to believe they stopped making Post Toasties. Please BRING THEM BACK.

Comment submitted: 2/15/2010 (#1430)

By I. Hope

Rating (out of 5):

Review of internet info indicates "they" ceased production in April 2006 - why I have no idea as it was the best cereal ever; maybe Kraft will be smart enough to bring it back, as indicated above. Dollar General advertised it today, in a new package even, but there's none in the store!?!

Comment submitted: 1/31/2010 (#1332)

By Trust

Toasties are actually getting ready for a return to store shelves. Start looking for them in January!

Comment submitted: 12/2/2009 (#996)

By O. Hoho

Rating (out of 5):

I used to like it when I was a kid. Do they still make it? I've looked for it on the shelves with no luck.

Comment submitted: 11/28/2009 (#971)

Connect With Mr Breakfast   MrBreakfast at FaceBook   Mr Breakfast On Twitter   Mr Breakfast On Pinterest