Vanilla Milkshake Pop-Tarts
New Product Review:

Vanilla Milkshake Pop-Tarts

From Kellogg's
Reviewed by Mr Breakfast on 7/7/2008

These Pop-Tarts have the least amount of flavor of any Pop-Tart I've ever tried. In fact, they have less flavor than any brand of toaster pastry I've ever tried.

Vanilla Milkshake Pop-Tarts are surprisingly short on vanilla. The most prominent taste is that of the dough. It's very sweet... but when sweetness has nothing to enhance or mingle with, what's the point? This Pop-Tart is dull.

If you like the frosting on Pop-Tarts and have ever wished you could get the same sugary frosting on the inside, you might want to try them. Everyone one else should stay away from this one.


Nutritional considerations:

Each toaster pastry has 200 calories, 6 grams of fat (2 grams saturated; 0 grams Trans), 35 grams of Carbs, less than 1 gram of dietary fiber, 2 grams of protein and 16 grams of sugar.

The price we paid: $1.99


 (1 out of 7 Golden Eggs)
Comments About This Product Review
What do you think of Vanilla Milkshake Pop-Tarts?
Official Member: Team BreakfastBy nicolbie (Team Breakfast Member)

Product Rating (out of 5):

I like the taste of these, but I think they're just extra sugary. I wouldn't mind just dipping them in milk.

Comment submitted: 4/29/2012 (#3101)



Official Member: Team BreakfastBy alaneyjaney (Team Breakfast Member)

Product Rating (out of 5):

I was disappointed to learn Kellogg's is discontinuing my FAVORITE PopTart... VANILLA MILKSHAKE. Some people drink coffee every morning for breakfast but I eat the Vanilla Milkshake PopTart. And now I don't know what I will eat because I don't care for any of the other ones. Please join me in letting Kellogg's hear the voices of those who are unhappy with their decision to discontinue the Vanilla Milkshake PopTart. They also discontinued the chocolate with white filling too.

Comment submitted: 2/12/2012 (#3014)



By michaela

Product Rating (out of 5):

It Is So DELICIOUS!!!!!! I Do not like The Crust Though.

Comment submitted: 8/24/2010 (#2484)



By Stokey

Product Rating (out of 5):

MADDDD Good. They are the only ones I eat.

Comment submitted: 4/30/2010 (#2302)



By blair

Product Rating (out of 5):

These are my favorite pop tarts.

Comment submitted: 3/4/2010 (#2198)



By domi

Product Rating (out of 5):

I ate one yesterday and I love these vanilla milkshake popterts. Thier even better than smores =)

Comment submitted: 1/1/2010 (#2064)



By melmax

Product Rating (out of 5):

Where did these go? They are the best pop-tarts ever!

Comment submitted: 12/3/2009 (#2029)



By skheartsmshake

Product Rating (out of 5):

Please, tell my local grocer to put them back on the shelves!

Comment submitted: 6/27/2009 (#1810)



By mshake recommen

Product Rating (out of 5):

I regret to say I've had sort of an addiction to pop tarts for a while. It started with the hot fudge sundae flavor but it's been milkshake for a long time now. I think they taste just like sugar cookies! My favorite!

Comment submitted: 6/27/2009 (#1809)



By Leafy

Product Rating (out of 5):

I'm eating some right now, after my brother just complained how disgusting they were. I personally think they're OK but nothing more. they have an interesting , and appealing taste, but I see how eating two of them could get boring. One is ok.

Comment submitted: 5/1/2009 (#1636)



By kronik

Blah! Spam is better than this!

Comment submitted: 4/27/2009 (#1623)



By scrooner

Product Rating (out of 5):

I had some of these last night, and within 20 minutes they completely cleaned out my insides. Holy cow, it was a colon blow. I will never eat these again... unless I get backed up.

Comment submitted: 4/7/2009 (#1578)



By heart vanilla

Product Rating (out of 5):

Loved these actually. I like the cake batter flavor of the vanilla, reminded me of desserts toasted with powdered sugar. Probably my favorite flavor in a long time.

Comment submitted: 4/4/2009 (#1569)



By Momof 3

Product Rating (out of 5):

These are easily the least appealing pop-tarts ever. Even my kids didn't care for them. The dough is the same, but the filling is a flavorless goo. It's like eating dough-flavored frosting.

Comment submitted: 2/23/2009 (#1483)



Official Member: Team BreakfastBy WafflesRock (Team Breakfast Member)

Product Rating (out of 5):

I actually thought these were really good. Unlike some other people have noted, I thought they tasted just like a vanilla version of the Hot Fudge Sundae Pop-Tarts, which are my favorite. Vanilla Milkshake Pop-Tarts might be a close second though!

Comment submitted: 1/28/2009 (#1421)



Official Member: Team BreakfastBy verby (Team Breakfast Member)

Product Rating (out of 5):

Had these recently, and I agree, they're pretty bland/boring. Once it was warm it seemed as though the filling melted and soaked into the dough, it's like it disappeared.

Comment submitted: 1/11/2009 (#1370)



By Potty Mouth

Product Rating (out of 5):

I liked this one.

Comment submitted: 11/5/2008 (#1293)



By I Like Them

Product Rating (out of 5):

These are actually my favorite next to smore!

Comment submitted: 10/3/2008 (#1247)



By shinai

Product Rating (out of 5):

I do sympathize with the taste of dough (actually to me, cake batter or cupcake batter) but i actually prefer it over the hot fudge sundae. i like the flavour itself, though very light. I don't agree that it has the least amount of flavour, but i can understand how you can say that especially compared to other flavours, like cherry or apple.

Comment submitted: 9/3/2008 (#1205)



By aarp

Product Rating (out of 5):

I'm eating one right now and it's delicious.

Comment submitted: 8/5/2008 (#1127)



By P

Product Rating (out of 5):

These are actually very good frozen. The filling's taste comes out a little better. It's funny, as I liked the vanilla half of the splitz, and these seem different.

Comment submitted: 7/10/2008 (#1087)



By Taylor

Product Rating (out of 5):

I recently bought these because I am a big fan of the Hot Fudge Sundae pop-tarts. I thought they would be very similar. However, I was wrong. All I could taste really was the dough. Interesting idea, horrible execution.

Comment submitted: 7/8/2008 (#1086)





Comment On This Product:

Enter Your Comments Here:



Rate This Product:


Rotten Pretty Bad Okay Very Good Awesome

I Prefer Not To Rate This Product


Security Question:
Please type the name of the cereal below.

Please type the name of this cereal in the space to the right

Please enter the name of the cereal to the left:








See All Breakfast Product Reviews


Connect With Mr Breakfast:

Mr Breakfast At FaceBook
Mr Breakfast On Twitter
Mr Breakfast On Pinterest




Most Recent
Product Reviews:
Retro Breakfast & Brunch Recipes
Check out our favorite vintage recipes from old magazine ads and recipe cards. Click here.