Tomato Bagel Sandwich (1 serving) 1 bagel - split and toasted 2 tablespoons cream cheese 1 tomato - thinly sliced salt and pepper to taste 3 fresh basil leaves Spread cream cheese on bagel halves. Top cream cheese with tomato slices. Sprinkle with salt and pepper. Top with fresh basil leaves. For Variation: Mix up the kind of bagel you use. I love an onion or everything bagel. Try replacing the the cream cheese with fresh Mozzarella and this becomes a Caprese Bagel Sandwich! A simple, but tasty, bagel sandwich with tomato, cream cheese and basil. Includes tip to make a Caprese Bagel Sandwich. Mr Breakfast would like to thank caroline for this recipe. Recipe number 320. Submitted 7/10/2002.